Kevin J. Maroney (womzilla) wrote,
Kevin J. Maroney
womzilla

  • Mood:
  • Music:

Best Graphic Story Hugo: Ooopsie!

From the final issue of Voyageur, the Worldcon newsletter produced by the Plokta Cabal:

While formatting the Hugo nomination list this morning, we discovered that Plokta fave author Paul Cornell (the next Neil Gaiman™) was apparently incorrectly bumped from the Hugo for Best Graphic Story.

Paul's Marvel comic Captain Britain & MI-13 received six nominations for Best Graphic Story and [his] Captain Britain & MI-13: Secret Invasion received eight nominations--but they are effectively the same thing, and fourteen nominations would have been enough to secure a place on the shortlist. Hmph!


Footnotes: CB&MI-13 was a short-lived ongoing series which debuted in 2008. It starred Captain Britain teamed up with MI-13, a group of agents of Britain's counter-magical forces special service, lead by Pete Wisdom, a Warren Ellis creation and former boyfriend of Kitty Pride. MI-13 were introduced in the earlier Cornell-scripted miniseries, Wisdom, in 2006-07, and featured, among other figures, Skrull John, a Skrull who habitually assumed the form of John Lennon. The current series ran 15 issues plus an annual and just finished last month. One of the evil forces they fight is the demonic Plokta. So it all ties back together, see?)

"Secret Invasion" was Marvel's big summer crossover for 2008, and drove the story line in the first four issues of the MI-13 ongoing, all of which appeared in 2008. So, yes, those are overlapping nominations and should definitely have been counted together. If the nominations for this work had been counted correctly, both Fables: War and Pieces and Serenity: Better Days would have been pushed off the final ballot.

What an appalling oversight!

I am not volunteering to administer the Best Graphic Story Hugo. No. I am not. I am not. No. Just bloody kill me if it looks like I'm doing that. If I volunteer to consult, please at least mock me.

ETA: In a comment on a later post, despot_liz points out that it's likely that the administrators who counted the nominations in this category tossed out the nominations for Captain Britain and MI-13 because it wasn't a nomination for "a single story". Given a) the small number of nominated items, b) the clear overlap between CB&MI13 and CB&MI13: Secret Invasion, and c) that this is the first year that the category was part of the Hugos, it seems astonishingly unsound to hold all the nominations to a standard of complete unambiguity.
Subscribe

  • Some comics worthy of consideration for 2015

    I am hurrying to get my Hugo nominations in (deadline is March 31!) and made up this list of the f/sf comics stories that came out/wrapped up in…

  • Comics Read, 2014

    In 2014, I read 1,281 comics on 254 separate days. Jeez. Later this month (it is now January), I will endeavor to suggest some titles for the Best…

  • #GamerGate, a righteous rant, and not forgetting

    The following text was written by my friend Greg Costikyan and posted to his blog at Gamasutra. It was then deleted by Gamasutra. If Greg asks me…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 6 comments